Potentially this will embolden opposition to the current government which could result in a more civilian style democracy for future Myanmar. One can dream🩵☮️🌈🌏
I can’t imagine what this judgement must mean for the Rohingyan victims! Also, as i just studied independence and impartiality of judges, I can’t help but wonder if Sebitunde’s dissent signifies something 🤔(given the assertion by many that this judgment would have an impact on the South African v Israel case). ofcourse with the fact that she’s not a sole dissenter here as she was in some previous orders in that case, perhaps there isn’t more to it. Just a thought that crossed my mind as I was reading!
Excellent analysis Yusra demystifying the important aspect of the Judgment. I was quite surprised to find Judge Tomka and Nolte disagreeing with the majority. I was also not sure about Judge Abraham. I imagine how it would turn out in a case of individual criminal responsibility. Will the threshold be high as the rights of accused and the different standards of proof will come in. I would also like you to reflect upon the relationship between International Humanitarian Law and Genocide which the court has discussed in this case from para 296-305.
In Tomka’s dissent he says individual criminal responsibility is the only way genocide can be assessed, essentially (!). Yes that IHL part is v important and has repercussions for the Gaza case
Thank you so much for your post and for standing up for the Rohingya community. It is truly encouraging to see their struggles, resilience, and rightful pursuit of justice being recognized. The Rohingya people have suffered so much, and I deeply appreciate your efforts to raise awareness and show respect for their community.
I am also grateful for your post and your support. Please know that I am always available and willing to collaborate with you if you are working on something positive for the Rohingya community. I would be honored to contribute in any way I can to support the community and help make a meaningful difference.
Thanks for your response. I am also available to work for you and with you. Don't forget to contact me if you need any help from me to work for my Rohingya community.
Thanks for this, I also just published an article on the topic - a very big and indeed important step in international law!
Indeed!
Potentially this will embolden opposition to the current government which could result in a more civilian style democracy for future Myanmar. One can dream🩵☮️🌈🌏
Love this!
I can’t imagine what this judgement must mean for the Rohingyan victims! Also, as i just studied independence and impartiality of judges, I can’t help but wonder if Sebitunde’s dissent signifies something 🤔(given the assertion by many that this judgment would have an impact on the South African v Israel case). ofcourse with the fact that she’s not a sole dissenter here as she was in some previous orders in that case, perhaps there isn’t more to it. Just a thought that crossed my mind as I was reading!
I think all the judges were likely thinking of what this judgment would mean for the next one; it would be difficult not to… (just my view!)
Excellent analysis Yusra demystifying the important aspect of the Judgment. I was quite surprised to find Judge Tomka and Nolte disagreeing with the majority. I was also not sure about Judge Abraham. I imagine how it would turn out in a case of individual criminal responsibility. Will the threshold be high as the rights of accused and the different standards of proof will come in. I would also like you to reflect upon the relationship between International Humanitarian Law and Genocide which the court has discussed in this case from para 296-305.
In Tomka’s dissent he says individual criminal responsibility is the only way genocide can be assessed, essentially (!). Yes that IHL part is v important and has repercussions for the Gaza case
Thank you so much for your post and for standing up for the Rohingya community. It is truly encouraging to see their struggles, resilience, and rightful pursuit of justice being recognized. The Rohingya people have suffered so much, and I deeply appreciate your efforts to raise awareness and show respect for their community.
I am also grateful for your post and your support. Please know that I am always available and willing to collaborate with you if you are working on something positive for the Rohingya community. I would be honored to contribute in any way I can to support the community and help make a meaningful difference.
Thank you for this kind note. I am delighted for your community; this was long overdue! I will message you privately as would love to stay in touch.
Thanks for your response. I am also available to work for you and with you. Don't forget to contact me if you need any help from me to work for my Rohingya community.
Here is my contact info -
Email - romaungsoemyint786@gmail.com
Thanks, we’ll be in touch!
Thank you for this very ckear explanation.
Thanks to you for reading ☺️
You saved me from reading the entire judgment. Superb piece.
Thanks, Yasir!
Great job getting this out so quickly! Very helpful summary and analysis.
Thank you, Craig! Looking forward to your own take! ☺️