Excellent legal breakdown, Dr. Suedi! The contradiction you highlighted regarding Article 12(3) and state succession is a brilliant catch. It exposes a fascinating paradox: while the deal is surprisingly structured around international law today, it actively attempts to short-circuit a future independent Greenland's sovereign right to determine its own geopolitical alignment. Forcing NATO compliance as a backdoor condition for future statehood is a massive strategic anchor. Terrific read!
Thanks Yusra for this article which summarises so well what everyone expected would be really complicated. I guess my concerns are around the lack of definition around what two new US defence bases might look like and the environmental controls around their construction and operation. I hope there are caveats and limits around these that maybe you didn't touch on here. I know it says everything to be agreed by Denmark and Greenland. But I'm just not trusting US if that is the only constraints. Perhaps you could comment on that. I love what you're doing here, trying to introduce us to International Law and it's fascinating. Bless you.☮️🩵🌈🌏
Thank you so much, great question! The US must propose "mitigating measures" for future bases that Denmark/Greenland must agree to. But "technical details" left to agree and no express environmental conditions. Also, nothing on clean-up or liability. So the real safeguard is whether Denmark/Greenland insist on strong terms when the details are negotiated. Watch this space, and thank you for the kind words!
I see your point about independence and right to choose for themselves. International agreements can change if there is political will.
About the agreement adding two more bases. The US used to have 17 bases/installations. Only Mestersvig is a new location, with an existing military base (Danish). The US could have build those bases without this deal if they had asked. Now they get to build them while also having to respect the Greenlandic way of life + the environment etc. (part of some o the 2004 agreements that this new one builds on).
Denmark and Greenland got a gun to their head, answered with group work and gave what they would have given anyway + formalized existing practices (consultation about foreign investment from outside EU and NATO).
Very nice read!
Honestly, I was expecting a much more aggressive deal than this.
Thanks for posting.
I was too! 😅 Thanks!
Excellent legal breakdown, Dr. Suedi! The contradiction you highlighted regarding Article 12(3) and state succession is a brilliant catch. It exposes a fascinating paradox: while the deal is surprisingly structured around international law today, it actively attempts to short-circuit a future independent Greenland's sovereign right to determine its own geopolitical alignment. Forcing NATO compliance as a backdoor condition for future statehood is a massive strategic anchor. Terrific read!
Many kind thanks! ☺️🙏🏽
Washington talks drilling. Nuuk writes the rules.
Thanks Yusra for this article which summarises so well what everyone expected would be really complicated. I guess my concerns are around the lack of definition around what two new US defence bases might look like and the environmental controls around their construction and operation. I hope there are caveats and limits around these that maybe you didn't touch on here. I know it says everything to be agreed by Denmark and Greenland. But I'm just not trusting US if that is the only constraints. Perhaps you could comment on that. I love what you're doing here, trying to introduce us to International Law and it's fascinating. Bless you.☮️🩵🌈🌏
Thank you so much, great question! The US must propose "mitigating measures" for future bases that Denmark/Greenland must agree to. But "technical details" left to agree and no express environmental conditions. Also, nothing on clean-up or liability. So the real safeguard is whether Denmark/Greenland insist on strong terms when the details are negotiated. Watch this space, and thank you for the kind words!
I see your point about independence and right to choose for themselves. International agreements can change if there is political will.
About the agreement adding two more bases. The US used to have 17 bases/installations. Only Mestersvig is a new location, with an existing military base (Danish). The US could have build those bases without this deal if they had asked. Now they get to build them while also having to respect the Greenlandic way of life + the environment etc. (part of some o the 2004 agreements that this new one builds on).
Denmark and Greenland got a gun to their head, answered with group work and gave what they would have given anyway + formalized existing practices (consultation about foreign investment from outside EU and NATO).
Thanks for these helpful comments!